Proof of cash rent payments, objections to rental debts, burden of proof, enforcement proceedings, and eviction procedures under Turkish law
One of the most common disputes arising from rental relationships occurs when a tenant claims to have paid the rent, while the landlord alleges that no payment was made. Such disputes can give rise to significant evidentiary difficulties, particularly when rent has been paid in cash rather than through a bank transfer.
So, how can a tenant prove that rent was paid in cash? What happens if a landlord initiates enforcement proceedings for unpaid rent? Does objecting to a payment order prevent eviction?
In this article, we examine how rental payments can be proven, the legal obligations of landlords and tenants, and the enforcement and eviction procedures that may arise from unpaid rent under Turkish law.
Table of Contents
- Who Bears the Burden of Proving Rent Payment?
- How Can Cash Rent Payments Be Proven?
- What Happens if a Tenant Cannot Provide a Receipt?
- What Happens if a Landlord Initiates Enforcement Proceedings?
- Does Objecting to a Rental Debt Prevent Eviction?
- How Is Rent Calculated When a Tenant Disputes the Rent Increase?
- Can a Tenant Be Evicted for Non-Payment of Rent?
- What Should Landlords and Tenants Pay Attention To?
- Conclusion
1. Who Bears the Burden of Proving Rent Payment?
Under Turkish law, the general principle is that a party must prove the facts from which they derive a legal right or benefit.
According to Article 190 of the Turkish Code of Civil Procedure (Law No. 6100), unless otherwise provided by law, the burden of proof rests with the party seeking to derive a legal consequence in their favour from the alleged facts.
This principle has an important consequence in rental relationships:
The landlord must establish the existence and amount of the rental claim, while the tenant who asserts that the debt has been paid bears the burden of proving payment.
Therefore, a tenant’s mere statement that “I paid the rent” is not sufficient to establish that the rental debt has been discharged.
Payment must be demonstrated through legally admissible evidence.
2. How Can Cash Rent Payments Be Proven?
Paying rent through a bank transfer creates an important record of the payment date, amount, and recipient.
By contrast, cash payments may create evidentiary difficulties, particularly where no written documentation has been issued.
Where a tenant claims to have paid rent in cash, the following forms of evidence may be relevant:
- Payment receipts signed by the landlord;
- Written documents in which the landlord acknowledges receiving payment;
- Messages and electronic correspondence confirming payment;
- Other documents lawfully obtained and admissible in the circumstances of the case;
- The judicial oath as evidence, where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
It is important to note that not every claim of payment can be proven through witness testimony.
Under the Turkish Code of Civil Procedure, the admissibility of witness testimony depends on the nature and monetary value of the dispute, as well as the applicable statutory exceptions to the requirement for documentary evidence.
In addition, the tax-related requirements concerning the documentation of rental payments through banks or the Turkish postal system (PTT) must be taken into account.
For these reasons, the safest method for tenants is to make rental payments through a bank transfer, clearly indicating the rental period to which each payment relates.
3. What Happens if a Tenant Cannot Provide a Receipt?
In practice, tenants sometimes claim that they have paid rent in cash for many years but never requested receipts due to the relationship of trust between themselves and their landlords.
In such circumstances, the dispute often centres on whether the alleged payments can be proven.
For example, suppose a landlord initiates enforcement proceedings on the grounds that rent for a particular month remains unpaid.
The tenant objects to the proceedings, claiming that the rent was paid in cash.
In this situation, the court examines the existence of the rental relationship, the amount of the claim, and whether payment has actually been established.
If the tenant cannot prove the alleged payment, they may be held liable for the outstanding rental debt.
The key issue is not only whether payment was actually made, but whether it can be legally proven if a dispute arises.
4. What Happens if a Landlord Initiates Enforcement Proceedings?
If rent is not paid when due, the landlord may initiate enforcement proceedings to recover the outstanding amount.
Articles 269 and following of the Turkish Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (Law No. 2004) regulate enforcement proceedings and eviction procedures arising from unpaid rent.
Where the statutory requirements are satisfied, the landlord may seek both recovery of the rental debt and eviction of the tenant through the relevant enforcement procedure.
When a payment order, commonly known as a Form No. 13 Payment Order, is served in relation to residential or roofed commercial premises, two important deadlines arise.
Seven-day objection period: As a general rule, the tenant may object to the payment order before the enforcement office within seven days of service.
Thirty-day payment period: Under Article 315 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, tenants of residential and roofed commercial premises must be granted at least thirty days to pay the outstanding rent.
These deadlines have different legal consequences.
An objection filed within the statutory period may suspend enforcement proceedings. However, an objection alone does not establish that the debt is invalid or automatically eliminate the possibility of eviction.
5. Does Objecting to a Rental Debt Prevent Eviction?
When a tenant objects to a payment order within the statutory period, the enforcement proceedings are suspended.
However, this does not prevent the landlord from pursuing further legal remedies.
Depending on the nature of the dispute, the landlord may, where the relevant legal requirements are satisfied, apply to the enforcement court for the removal of the objection or initiate an action for the annulment of the objection before the competent court.
In an action for annulment of objection, the court examines the existence and amount of the rental claim, the payments allegedly made, and the evidence submitted by the parties.
Where eviction is also sought due to non-payment of rent, the court must additionally examine whether the legal requirements for tenant default have been satisfied.
Therefore, objecting to enforcement proceedings and extinguishing a rental debt are two legally distinct matters.
An eviction order may be issued only where the conditions prescribed by law have been met.
6. How Is Rent Calculated When a Tenant Disputes the Rent Increase?
Rental disputes do not always concern whether payment has been made. In some cases, the parties also disagree about the amount of rent legally payable.
Particularly in long-standing rental agreements, differences may arise between contractual rent increase clauses and the statutory limits applicable to rent increases.
Article 344 of the Turkish Code of Obligations (Law No. 6098) sets out the fundamental rules governing rent increases during renewed rental periods.
For residential and roofed commercial leases, agreements concerning rent increases upon renewal are generally valid provided that the increase does not exceed the twelve-month average change in the Consumer Price Index (CPI) for the preceding rental year.
However, when calculating rental claims relating to previous years, the legislation applicable during the relevant period must be considered.
For example, the temporary 25% cap on rent increases that applied to residential leases during certain periods may affect calculations concerning those periods. This temporary restriction expired on 1 July 2024.
Consequently, calculating a rental claim relating to previous years may require more than simply applying the current rent increase rate.
The commencement date of the lease, renewal periods, contractual rent adjustment clauses, and legislation applicable during each relevant period must be assessed together.
7. Can a Tenant Be Evicted for Non-Payment of Rent?
Under Article 315 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, if a tenant fails to pay rent or ancillary expenses when due, the landlord may grant the tenant a written period within which to make payment and notify the tenant that the agreement will be terminated if payment is not made.
For residential and roofed commercial leases, this period must be at least thirty days.
A payment order served in enforcement proceedings initiated in accordance with the statutory requirements may also fulfil the necessary notice function.
Failure to pay the debt within the prescribed period may give rise to eviction proceedings based on the tenant’s default.
However, an allegation of unpaid rent does not automatically entitle the landlord to evict the tenant.
The proceedings must be initiated properly, the payment order must be duly served, the statutory deadlines must be observed, and the existence of the rental debt and the conditions for default must be assessed.
8. What Should Landlords and Tenants Pay Attention To?
A significant number of rental disputes arise because payment records are not properly maintained or arrangements between the parties are not documented in writing.
For tenants, it is important to pay rent on time through a bank transfer and clearly specify the relevant rental period in the payment description.
Where payment is made in cash, obtaining a signed receipt may provide important protection in the event of a future dispute.
For landlords, keeping accurate records of rental payments received, determining rent increases in accordance with the applicable legislation, and observing statutory deadlines in proceedings concerning unpaid rent are equally important.
In disputes involving rental claims from previous periods, correctly calculating the rent payable can be crucial both to the scope of the claim and to the outcome of the proceedings.
Conclusion
Claiming that rent has been paid and legally proving that payment are not the same thing.
A tenant’s assertion that rent was paid in cash may not, by itself, be sufficient to establish that the rental debt has been discharged.
Where payment cannot be proven, the tenant may face enforcement proceedings for outstanding rent and, if the relevant legal conditions are satisfied, eviction proceedings.
At the same time, the landlord must establish the legal basis and amount of the rental claim.
The terms of the rental agreement, payment records, rent increase rates, nature of the enforcement proceedings, and applicable statutory deadlines must all be considered when resolving a rental dispute.
For this reason, obtaining an appropriate legal assessment at an early stage may be important in avoiding potential loss of rights.
Malabega Hukuk | Real Estate and Rental Law
This article has been prepared for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or a legal opinion concerning any particular dispute. Each case must be evaluated in light of its specific circumstances.